Nahlah
Ayed's A Thousand Farewells: A Reporter's Journey from Refugee Camp
to the Arab Spring (Toronto: Penguin/Viking, 2012)
This
non-fiction book appealed to me because Nahlah Ayed is an
Arab-speaking journalist who was born is Winnipeg and attended my
Alma Mater, the University of Manitoba. A Thousand Farewells
documents her seven years working for the CBC, living in and
reporting from the Middle East, from about 2005 to 2012, up to the
Tahrir Square protest in Egypt and the beginning of "the Arab
Spring."
Ayed's
account is eye-opening to me. I know next to nothing about the
geography and the human history of this troubled region. News reports
seem catastrophic, confusing, and predictably pessimistic. The best I
can hope to do is to assist, or support my government's assistance,
in whatever way is realistic and to try to do no harm. (For example,
by not bombing, which hurts innocent individuals, property, and the
economy.)
In A
Thousand Farewells, Ayed attempts to explain to the uninitiated,
across cultures, the events, the issues, their historic origins, the
current context, and the way they impact individuals. She
communicates her understanding of her mandate as one verbalizing and
then writing first drafts of history. She stresses her credo that
"People are not quotes or clips, used to illustrate stories
about war and conflict. People are the story, always." And she
does not stint on sharing facts about the stresses and physical
threats of living in, rushing towards, war zones. An existence, as
they say, like the pinball in the machine, moved by, responding to,
the actions of others. Subsuming any semblance of a personal life to
the demands of career and calling.
Ayed's
account is by no means prescriptive. She shares what she knows,
gathered from observation, experience, interviews, and reading.
Several motifs and themes stand out for me. That the Middle East is
not a place of homogeneity. That there are many different groups,
including many different Muslim groups. That many of the conflicts
and rivalries have ancient roots. That in some ways, religion is the
opiate, encouraging people to accept the status quo. That the status
quo includes fewer rights for women. That when refugees flee, they
are "voting with their feet." That when colonial powers
interfere, it almost always makes things worse. That equating
democracy with majority rule will be problematic (as religious
extreme parties may be voted in to replace dictators or military
rule). That the focus will be on "human rights" for
everyone, including the right to citizenship. That any successful
change must come from within.
Ayed
witnessed events which helped her feel optimistic. In Egypt, people
lost their fear and assembled and voiced their opposition to a
dictatorship. And, during one of the protests, she saw Muslims
protecting Christians and Christians protecting Muslims, taking turns
while the other group prayed.
Reading
A Thousand Farewells has made me both a better Canadian and a better
citizen of the world.
No comments:
Post a Comment